Top 10 Best Crib Mattresses in 2023 Reviews

Last updated on July 16, 2023

A mattress is as vital as a bed. The same case applies to crib mattresses. They are essential for giving babies comfort when sleeping. Since babies spend the most time in asleep, it’s critical to keep baby bed secure. With right cribs bedding materials, they ensure babies wake up while relaxed. Soft or tough mattresses can cause sleeping issues. It, therefore, calls for recommended mattresses to give little angels the best sleeping experience.

Usually, many issues can arise when you choose wrong bending. Some can increase suffocation, while others can increase pressure on the spine. Therefore, buying a mattress for babies requires great considerations. It calls for a deeper examination apart from looking at the physical appearance. Additionally, these days, there are different types of mattresses which give parents a variety of choice.

10. Graco Premium Foam Crib & Toddler Mattress

Graco Premium Foam Crib & Toddler Mattress

Check Price on Amazon

The Graco premium mattress is a perfect choice for your babies. It’s a high-quality foam mattress made from safe materials. With high convenience, this mattress offers easy usage. Manufactured without strong smells, the bed is safe and doesn’t cause strong odors. The firm design is classic since it allows the baby to enjoy great support. This eliminates the risk of sinking, which can lead to suffocation. For durability, the mattress is fitted with a water-resistant cover. This cover is ideal since it keeps mattress safe from bedwetting damage.

The balanced firmness is excellent in ensuring your baby has the best experience. With removable and washable cover, it’s easy to keep it clean. In fact, it is enhanced with a zipper which creates ease of removal. The safety of kids is superb since the mattress is free from phthalates, lead, and other materials.


  • High-quality memory foam
  • Zipper enhanced cover
  • Washable and waterproof cover


  • Not machine washable

9. Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams Hypoallergenic Crib Bed

Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams Hypoallergenic Crib Bed

Check Price on Amazon

Babies spend most of their time sleeping. It is, therefore, advisable to ensure they have the right beds. Safety 1st heavenly dreams mattress gives every baby fantastic sleep. Experts on baby matters make this mattress hence superb for maintaining comfort and support. In fact, it’s lightweight and delivers unmatched support to kids. In fact, the bed can support up to 50 pounds without causing sinking. Boasting hypoallergenic materials, the mattress is superb for keeping kids healthy.

With this toddler mattress, it offers ideal usage without suffering from wetting due to urine. The cover is water-resistant, which is superb for the mattress durability. Unlike other cheap beddings, this mattress is Greenguard gold to offer the highest safety and comfort. Amazingly, it has excellent compatibility with a standard crib and toddler beds. The outer cover is vinyl made, which enhances high breathability. Therefore, babies enjoy comfortable sleep without hot spots.


  • Breathable vinyl cover
  • Compatible with most crib beds
  • Water-resistant


  • The cover isn’t removable

8. Milliard Crib Mattress Dual Comfort System

Milliard Crib Mattress Dual Comfort System

Check Price on Amazon

When parents want to give their toddlers a superb sleeping platform, a mattress is exceptional. It’s a versatile mattress that grows with your baby. Actually, it has a soft side for older babes and firmer side for infants. As a result, parents can trust this mattress for the comfort and safety of their kids. Also, the bed guarantees high durability and babies can use it for a longer period. The adaptive memory foam keeps babies safe and comfortable and reliable.

The cover is cotton made and waterproof. This ensures babies don’t cause damage to mattress due to wetting. Also, the cover is washable to maintain the bed refreshing. Due to the cotton fabrics, the mattress feels comfortable and is breathable. Possessing all superior foam qualities, the mattress is durable and safe for every kid. Measuring 52’’ x 27.5’’ x 5.5’’, it can fit most standard sized crib beds.


  • Cotton mattress cover
  • Versatile mattress sides
  • Hypoallergenic memory foam


  • Slight smell when new

7. Moonlight Slumber Reversible Baby Crib Mattress

Moonlight Slumber Reversible Baby Crib Mattress

Check Price on Amazon

Moonlit Slumber baby mattress provides exceptional support and comfort. It’s among the top quality options when it comes to versatility and support for your baby. In fact, the reversible design keeps it performing excellently. With one side for toddlers and the other for infants, there are no risks of suffocations. The ecofriendly plant-based memory foam renders the mattress safe and free from strong chemical smells. Amazingly, the medical-grade fabrics used in this mattress make it safe and comfortable.

Apart from being breathable, the fabrics are naturally fire retardant. Therefore, the mattress has no smell due to low VOC. Despite being waterproof, the mattress delivers great ease in cleaning. This helps to keep babies enjoying odor and dirt-free environment. Due to thorough testing, the bed offers great reliability and performance for a long time. Perfected sewing allows the mattress to be resistant to bedbugs, dust, and mites.


  • Natural fire retardant fabrics
  • Eco-friendly memory foam
  • Dust and bedbug resistant


  • Cheap outer cover

6. My First Crib Mattress Hypoallergenic Foam Crib Mattress

My First Crib Mattress Hypoallergenic Foam Crib Mattress

Check Price on Amazon

Let your babies sleep while enjoying excellent safety and comfort. My first crib mattress is one of the remarkable and reliable ways to enjoy exceptional reliability. It’s a premium mattress that suits all your infant needs. Unlike other mattresses, this features CertiPUR-US memory foam. Precisely, flexible Polyurethane foam is soft and highly supportive. The construction features kids in mind. Therefore, it boasts a waterproof cover that keeps the mattress durable for long.

The mattress is PVC free, which is great for the safety of your kids. It, therefore, ensures spills and urine don’t leak into the foam. The construction exceeds all the set standards, which allow for high reliability. Whether it’s the quality or firmness, the mattress is exceptional. Apart from the proper support, the bed is hypoallergenic. The mite proof cover is also resistant to dust. For safety, the mattress features flame-resistant materials.


  • Exceeds flammability test
  • Hypoallergenic and mite proof
  • High flexibility


  • Leaves gaps in the edges

5. Big Oshi Non-Toxic Foam Crib Mattress

Big Oshi Non-Toxic Foam Crib Mattress

Check Price on Amazon

Making your crib ideal for your toddlers requires comfortable mattresses. Big Oshi crib bedding brings amazing relaxation for babies. The enhanced versatility makes the mattress ideal for toddlers and infants. Therefore, it offers a great transition from infant to toddler. The improved design lets parents enjoy superb safety for their kids. This mattress comes in a compressed box and takes the least time to decompress. With a slight smell, it doesn’t need a long time to degas like other mattresses.

The thick design is ideal when it comes to the kids’ comfort. Exceeding set flammability tests, the mattress is exceptional for the safety of babies. Additionally, the bed is free from phthalates, BPA and other prohibited materials. This mattress is recommended by pediatricians’ hence great quality for all parents. Since this is an orthopedic mattress, it provides balanced support, comfort, and general safety. Simple to clean cover is also waterproof for the protection of your babies.


  • Washable waterproof cover
  • Orthopedic design
  • Reversible applications


  • Pain to assemble

4. Sealy Soybean Crib Mattress

Sealy Soybean Crib Mattress

Check Price on Amazon

The Sealy mattress for crib beds is one of the exceptional choices. Unlike other mattresses, this features soybean foam, which is safe and natural. It has excellent smell and safety compared to synthetic memory foams. Besides safety, the bed is eco-friendly and helps in sustainable production. With careful production, it’s free from prohibited materials like mercury, lead, and BPA. In fact, the bed is CertiPUR-US certified hence ideal for every kid to use.

Apart from safety, the mattress offers great durability. Enhanced with reinforced embossed waterproof cover, it keeps the bed dry. Therefore, no more struggling to add mattress pads to prevent damage by urine. Due to the textured cover, it keeps the baby comfortable. High breathability is the reason the mattress offers many parents great peace of mind. The cotton wrap is super soft and comfortable hence allowing kids to enjoy sleeping. Above all, the right firmness eliminates suffocations and discomfort.


  • Natural soybeans foam
  • Soft cotton wrap
  • Locks stitching


  • Slightly small edges

3. Dream On Me 3″ Pocket Coil Portable Crib Mattress

Dream On Me 3

Check Price on Amazon

Dream On Me portable crib mattress is the right selection for all parents. The mattress has a balanced firmness to cater for kids. Made from polyurethane foam, is sturdy and soft. Also, the memory foam is free from strong smells that can cause health complications. Apart from the foam, this mattress features coil springs for reinforced comfort. The coils are wrapped in hypoallergenic foam to increase the support. Unlike others that have hard coils, this maintains soft nature throughout.

The venting design, the lock stitching ensure efficient cooling and air circulation. This helps to prevent hot nights that can compromise comfort. With a waterproof cover, there is superior protection stains water leaking into the mattress. Therefore, even when babies are sleeping, no damage by urine, and other spills. Additionally, the cover is antibacterial, hypoallergenic, and mold resistant. The easy to clean cover makes it simple for parents and babies to enjoy peace of mind.


  • Antibacterial cover
  • Wrapped coils springs
  • Mildew resistant


  • Not fit for newborns

2. Dourxi Lightweight Mattress

Dourxi Lightweight Mattress

Check Price on Amazon

Dourxi lightweight mattress is amazingly suited for your baby cribs. Made from memory foam core, it perfumes excellently when it comes to support. Despite the dense foam, the mattress has excellent airflow for a luxurious feeling. Amazingly, the bed provides proper cooling, which is ideal for newborns. Besides giving great support, the mattress boasts a removable cover. It’s washable, which allows parents to keep it clean. The durable and safe sewn seams are excellent and protect the bed from harboring bedbugs.

Apart from the soft cover, it has a sleek look. Also, the design ensures it allows air trapping, which helps in cooling the baby. As a result, even when spending a lot of time in bed, there are no heat discomforts. Overall, the mattress is lightweight, which increases portability. Packed in a safe box, it ensures transportation is simple and decompressions. The certified quality and construction ensure there is ultimate safety for your baby.


  • Ventilated foam
  • Quilted washable cover
  • Rayon fiber barrier


  • Takes long to attain full size

1. NapYou Dual Comfort Reversible Side Crib Mattress

NapYou Dual Comfort Reversible Side Crib Mattress

Check Price on Amazon

The NapYou dual sides crib mattress is guaranteeing superb baby comfort. It’s sturdy and firmly made mattresses that fit most standard cribs and toddler beds. The supportive memory foam is sturdy to give babies ample support and eliminate suffocation. The soft side is ideal for toddlers while the firm surface is perfected for newborns. This provides the baby with perfect body support and prevents suffocation which can lead to sudden death syndrome.

The sleek mattress cover is not only beautiful, but, it creates a great feeling. It has a waterproof design that allows for the mattress to enjoy improved durability. There is no damage from spills, water, urine, and other liquids. Consequently, the mattress is ideal to use even without using mattress protectors. The organic cotton cover is soft and highly breathable making the baby to enjoy spending time on the bed.


  • Cotton blended cover
  • Dual comfort design
  • Supports proper posture


  • Feels thin

Crib Mattresses Buying Guide

Type of mattress

The kind of bed is vital for overall comfort and support. There are memory foam and innerspring mattresses. However, for better performance, most baby mattresses are made from memory foam. The material is durable and reliable. Also, foam mattresses are classic for ensuring both sides are usable. With this, it is possible to use these mattresses for infants and toddlers due to difference in firmness.


The cover is as important as the mattresses. Since different brands use varying cover materials, comfort also differs. Mostly, looking for the breathable and waterproof cover is vital. The type of fabrics also matters in determining comfort and performance. Cotton and polyester materials are typical among different mattresses. Besides comfort, ensure the cover is waterproof and simple to clean.


Weight is another factor that determines how convenient your baby mattress is. In most cases, lightweight ones are ideal even when for families traveling since they are easy to carry. Depending on the type and quality of materials, the weight always differs.


The breathability of a mattress is vital for the sleeper. Usually, venting is essential for any bed to allow free air circulation. This eliminates hot sleeping, which can cause excessive sweating. Also, cooling mattresses are great since they enhance comfort.


Crib mattresses are lasting solutions for babies. Unlike regular mattresses, these are made to suit kids perfectly. They provide perfect support and comfort without straining baby bodies. To guarantee toddler comfort and healthy development, the best mattresses are vital.

Related posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *